5614 
5271本文采用组织经济学的分析框架，对研发联盟的组织与治理研究进行了全面总结和梳理。我们从组织的关键维度来界定研发联盟，并阐述了技术特征、行业特征和企业特征对研发联盟组建的影响。我们认为，参与方需要在事前基于组织形式、合作伙伴特征以及研发合作的固有属性，为研发联盟选择相匹配的各种正式治理机制或非正式机制。从最大化社会福利的角度看，无论在研发联盟的组建还是治理方面，政府都应该运用适当的政策工具来提高研发联盟成功运作的可能并提升其研发绩效。文章最后指出了该领域未来进一步研究的若干方向。
研发联盟组织治理研究述评及未来展望
摘要
参考文献
1 李纪珍. 产业共性技术供给体系[M]. 北京:中国金融出版社,2004.
2 潘铁,柳卸林. 日本超大规模集成电路项目合作开发的启示[J]. 科学学研究,2008,（S2）:337–344.
3 Abramovsky L,Kremp E,López A,et al. Understanding co-operative innovative activity:Evidence from four European countries[J]. Economics of Innovation and New Technology,2009,18（3）:243–265.
4 Aerts K,Schmidt T. Two for the price of one? Additionality effects of R & D subsidies:A comparison between Flanders and Germany[J]. Research Policy,2008,37（5）:806–822.
5 Agarwal R,Croson R,Mahoney J T. The role of incentives and communication in strategic alliances:An experimental investigation[J]. Strategic Management Journal,2010,31（4）:413–437.
6 Amaldoss W,Staelin R. Cross-function and same-function alliances:How does alliance structure affect the behavior of partnering firms?[J]. Management Science,2010,56（2）:302–317.
7 Amir R,Wooders J. One-way spillovers,endogenous innovator/imitator roles,and research joint ventures[J]. Games and Economic Behavior,2000,31（1）:1–25.
8 Arranz N,de Arroyabe J C F. Effect of formal contracts,relational norms and trust on performance of joint research and development projects[J]. British Journal of Management,2012,23（4）:575–588.
9 Atallah G. R & D cooperation with asymmetric spillovers[J]. Canadian Journal of Economics/Revue canadienne d’économique,2005,38（3）:919–936.
10 Atallah G. Research joint ventures with asymmetric spillovers and symmetric contributions[J]. Economics of Innovation and New Technology,2007,16（7）:559–586.
11 Baumol W J. The free market innovation machine:Analyzing the growth miracle of capitalism[M]. Princeton,New Jersey:Princeton University Press,2002.
12 Becker B. Public R & D policies and private R & D investment:A survey of the empirical evidence[J]. Journal of Economic Surveys,2015,29（5）:917–942.
13 Belderbos R,Carree M,Diederen B,et al. Heterogeneity in R & D cooperation strategies[J]. International Journal of Industrial Organization,2004b,22（8–9）:1237–1263.
14 Belderbos R,Carree M,Lokshin B. Cooperative R & D and firm performance[J]. Research Policy,2004a,33（10）:1477–1492.
15 Berg S V,Duncan J,Friedman P. Joint venture strategies and corporate innovation[M]. Cambridge:Oelgeschlager,Gunn & Hain,1982.
16 Besanko D,Wu J J. The impact of market structure and learning on the tradeoff between R & D competition and cooperation[J]. The Journal of Industrial Economics,2013,61（1）:166–201.
17 Bloch F. Endogenous Structures of association in oligopolies[J]. The RAND Journal of Economics,1995,26（3）:537–556.
18 Bouncken R B,Clau T,Fredrich V. Product innovation through coopetition in alliances:Singular or plural governance?[J]. Industrial Marketing Management,2016,53:77–90.
19 Bouncken R B,Fredrich V. Coopetition:Performance implications and management antecedents[J]. International Journal of Innovation Management,2012,16（5）:1250028–1–1250028–28.
20 Branstetter L G,Sakakibara M. Japanese research consortia:A microeconometric analysis of industrial policy[J]. The Journal of Industrial Economics,1998,46（2）:207–233.
21 Branstetter L G,Sakakibara M. When do research consortia work well and why? Evidence from Japanese panel data[J]. American Economics Review,2002,92（1）:143–159.
22 Cabon-Dhersin M L,Ramani S V. Does trust matter for R & D cooperation? A game theoretic examination[J]. Theory and Decision,2004,57（2）:143–180.
23 Carboni O A. R & D subsidies and private R & D expenditures:Evidence from Italian manufacturing data[J]. International Review of Applied Economics,2011,25（4）:419–439.
24 Cassiman B,Veugelers R. R & D cooperation and spillovers:Some empirical evidence from Belgium[J]. American Economic Review,2002,92（4）:1169–1184.
25 Chiesa V,Manzini R. Organizing for technological collaborations:A managerial perspective[J]. R & D Management,1998,28（3）:199–212.
26 Cohen W M,Levinthal D A. Innovation and learning:The two faces of R & D[J]. The Economic Journal,1989,99（397）:569–596.
27 Cohen W M,Levinthal D A. Absorptive capacity:A new perspective on learning and innovation[J]. Administrative Science Quarterly,1990,35（1）:128–152.
28 Cooper R W,Ross T W. Sustaining cooperation with joint ventures[J]. Journal of Law,Economics, & Organization,2009,25（1）:31–54.
29 Czarnitzki D,Kraft K. Spillovers of innovation activities and their profitability[J]. Oxford Economic Papers,2012,64（2）:302–322.
30 Czarnitzki D,Delanote J. R & D policies for young SMEs:Input and output effects[J]. Small Business Economics,2015,45（3）:465–485.
31 D'Aspremont C,Jacquemin A. Cooperative and noncooperative R & D in duopoly with spillovers[J]. American Economic Review,1988,78（5）:1133–1137.
32 David P A,Hall B H,Toole A A. Is public R & D a complement or substitute for private R & D? A review of the econometric evidence[J]. Research Policy,2000,29（4–5）:497–529.
33 de Bondt R. Spillovers and innovative activities[J]. International Journal of Industrial Organization,1997,15（1）:1–28.
34 Deitz G D,Tokman M,Richey R G,et al. Joint venture stability and cooperation:Direct,indirect and contingent effects of resource complementarity and trust[J]. Industrial Marketing Management,2010,39（5）:862–873.
35 de Laat P B. Dangerous liaisons: Sharing knowledge within research and development alliances[A]. Grandori A. Interfirm networks: Organization and industrial competitiveness[M]. London: Routledge, 2014: 208–233.
36 de Faria P,Lima F,Santos R. Cooperation in innovation activities:The importance of partners[J]. Research Policy,2010,39（8）:1082–1092.
37 Dixit A K. Lawlessness and economics:Alternative modes of governance[M]. Princeton:Princeton University Press,2004.
38 Frankort H T W,Hagedoorn J,Letterie W. R & D partnership portfolios and the inflow of technological knowledge[J]. Industrial and Corporate Change,2012,21（2）:507–537.
39 Fritsch M,Lukas R. Who cooperates on R & D?[J]. Research Policy,2001,30（2）:297–312.
40 Ghosh M,John G. Governance value analysis and marketing strategy[J]. Journal of Marketing,1999,63:131–145.
41 Gnyawali D R,Park B J. Co-opetition between giants:Collaboration with competitors for technological innovation[J]. Research Policy,2011,40（5）:650–663.
42 Grossman G M,Shapiro C. Research joint venture:An antitrust analysis[J]. Journal of Law,Economics, & Organization,1986,2（2）:315–337.
43 Gulati R. Does familiarity breed trust? The implications of repeated ties for contractual choice in alliances[J]. Academy of Management Journal,1995,38（1）:85–112.
44 Gulati R,Singh H. The architecture of cooperation:Managing coordination costs and appropriation concerns in strategic alliances[J]. Administrative Science Quarterly,1998,43（4）:781–814.
45 Hall B,van Reenen J. How effective are fiscal incentives for R & D? A review of the evidence[J]. Research Policy,2000,29（4–5）:449–469.
46 Hart O D. Incomplete contracts and the theory of the firm[J]. Journal of Law,Economics, & Organization,1988,4（1）:119–139.
47 Hoetker G,Mellewigt T. Choice and performance of governance mechanisms:Matching alliance governance to asset type[J]. Strategic Management Journal,2009,30（10）:1025–1044.
48 Hyytinen A,Toivanen O. Do financial constraints hold back innovation and growth? Evidence on the role of public policy[J]. Research Policy,2005,34（9）:1385–1403.
49 Inkpen A C,Currall S C. The coevolution of trust,control,and learning in joint ventures[J]. Organization Science,2004,15（5）:586–599.
50 Kaiser U. An empirical test of models explaining research expenditures and research cooperation:Evidence for the German service sector[J]. International Journal of Industrial Organization,2002,20（6）:747–774.
51 Kale P,Dyer J H,Singh H. Alliance capability,stock market response,and long-term alliance success:The role of the alliance function[J]. Strategic Management Journal,2002,23（8）:747–767.
52 Kamien M I,Muller E,Zang I. Research joint ventures and R & D Cartels[J]. American Economic Review,1992,82（5）:1293–1306.
53 Katz M L. An analysis of cooperative research and development[J]. The RAND Journal of Economics,1986,17（4）:527–543.
54 Kim C S,Inkpen A C. Cross-border R & D alliances,absorptive capacity and technology learning[J]. Journal of International Management,2005,11（3）:313–329.
55 König M, Liu X D, Zenou Y. R & D networks: Theory, empirics and policy implications[R]. Working Paper No.142, 2014.
56 Krishnan R,Martin X,Noorderhaven N G. When does trust matter to alliance performance?[J]. Academy of Management Journal,2006,49（5）:894–917.
57 Kuittinen H,Kylheiko K,Sandstrm J,et al. Cooperation governance mode:An extended transaction cost approach[J]. Journal of Management and Governance,2009,13（4）:303–323.
58 Lach S. Do R & D subsidies stimulate or displace private R & D? Evidence from Israel[J]. The Journal of Industrial Economics,2002,50（4）:369–390.
59 Lenox M,King A. Prospects for developing absorptive capacity through internal information provision[J]. Strategic Management Journal,2004,25（4）:331–345.
60 Levin R C,Klevorick A K,Nelson R R,et al. Appropriating the returns from industrial research and development[J]. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity,1987,（3）:783–831.
61 Levy N. Technology sharing and tacit collusion[J]. International Journal of Industrial Organization,2012,30（2）:204–216.
62 Lhuillery S,Pfister E. R & D cooperation and failures in innovation projects:Empirical evidence from French CIS data[J]. Research Policy,2009,38（1）:45–57.
63 López A. Determinants of R & D cooperation:Evidence from Spanish manufacturing firms[J]. International Journal of Industrial Organization,2008,26（1）:113–136.
64 Luo X M,Rindfleisch A,Tse D K. Working with rivals:The impact of competitor alliances on financial performance[J]. Journal of Marketing Research,2007,44（1）:73–83.
65 Manasakis C,Petrakis E,Zikos V. Downstream research joint venture with upstream market power[J]. Southern Economic Journal,2014,80（3）:782–802.
66 Mazé A,Ménard C. Private ordering,collective action,and the self-enforcing range of contracts[J]. European Journal of Law and Economics,2010,29（1）:131–153.
67 Ménard C. The economics of hybrid organizations[J]. Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics JITE,2004,160（3）:345–376.
68 Meuleman M,de Maeseneire W. Do R & D subsidies affect SEMs’ access to external financing?[J]. Research Policy,2012,41（3）:580–591.
69 Mindruta D,Moeen M,Agarwal R. A two-sided matching approach for partner selection and assessing complementarities in partners’ attributes in inter-firm alliances[J]. Strategic Management Journal,2016,37（1）:206–231.
70 Miotti L,Sachwald F. Co-operative R & D:Why and with whom? An integrated framework of analysis[J]. Research Policy,2003,32（8）:1481–1499.
71 Miyagiwa K. Collusion and research joint ventures[J]. The Journal of Industrial Economics,2009,57（4）:768–784.
72 Nelson R R. The sources of economic growth[M]. Cambridge:Harvard University Press,1996.
73 Okamuro H,Kato M,Honjo Y. Determinants of R & D cooperation in Japanese start-ups[J]. Research Policy,2011,40（5）:728–738.
74 Reuer J J,Zollo M. Termination outcomes of research alliances[J]. Research Policy,2005,34（1）:101–115.
75 Riechmann T,Weimann J. Competition as a coordination device:Experimental evidence from a minimum effort coordination game[J]. European Journal of Political Economy,2008,24（2）:437–454.
76 Ritala P,Hurmelinna-Laukkanen P. Incremental and radical innovation in coopetition-the role of absorptive capacity and appropriability[J]. Journal of Product Innovation Management,2013,30（1）:154–169.
77 Rller L H,Siebert R,Tombak M M. Why firms form （or do not form） RJVS[J]. The Economic Journal,2007,117（522）:1122–1144.
78 Sakakibara M. Formation of R & D consortia:Industry and company effects[J]. Strategic Management Journal,2002,23（11）:1033–1050.
79 Sampson R C. The cost of misaligned governance in R & D alliances[J]. The Journal of Law,Economics, & Organization,2004,20（2）:484–526.
80 Schumpeter J A. Capitalism,socialism & democracy[M]. London:Allen and Unwin,1942.
81 Schiavone F,Simoni M. Prior experience and co-opetition in R & D programs[J]. Journal of the Knowledge Economy,2015:1–17,doi:10.1007/s13132–015-0251-x. DOI:10.1007/s13132–015-0251-x
82 Silipo D B. Incentives and forms of cooperation in research and development[J]. Research in Economics,2008,62（2）:101–119.
83 Tassey G. The economics of R & D policy[M]. New York:Quorum Books,1997.
84 Tassey G. Choosing government R & D policies:Tax incentives vs. direct funding[J]. Review of Industrial Organization,1996,11（5）:579–600.
85 Tripsas M,Schrader S,Sobrero M. Discouraging opportunistic behavior in collaborative R & D:A new role for government[J]. Research Policy,1995,24（3）:367–389.
86 Tyler B B,Steensma H K. Evaluating technological collaborative opportunities:A cognitive modeling perspective[J]. Strategic Management Journal,1995,16（S1）:43–70.
87 Vandekerckhove J,de Bondt R. Asymmetric spillovers and investments in research and development of leaders and followers[J]. Economics of Innovation and New Technology,2008,17（5）:417–433.
88 Veugelers R. Internal R & D expenditures and external technology sourcing[J]. Research Policy,1997,26（3）:303–315.
89 von Raesfeld A,Geurts P,Jansen M. When is a network a nexus for innovation? A study of public nanotechnology R & D projects in the Netherlands[J]. Industrial Marketing Management,2012,41（5）:752–758.
90 Williamson O E. Market and hierarchies:Analysis and antitrust implication[M]. New York:The Free Press,1975.
91 Williamson O E. Public and private bureaucracies:A transaction cost economics perspectives[J]. Journal of Law,Economics, & Organization,1999,15（1）:306–342.
92 Williamson O E. The new institutional economics:Taking stock,looking ahead[J]. Journal of Economic Literature,2000,38（3）:595–613.
93 Williamson O E. Transaction cost economics[A]. Ménard C, Shirley M M. Handbook of new institutional economics[M]. US: Springer, 2005: 41–65.
94 Williamson O E. Transaction cost economics:The natural progression[J]. Journal of Retailing,2010,86（3）:215–226.
95 Wu J. Technological collaboration in product innovation:The role of market competition and sectoral technological intensity[J]. Research Policy,2012,41（2）:489–496.
96 Wu J. Cooperation with competitors and product innovation:Moderating effects of technological capability and alliances with universities[J]. Industrial Marketing Management,2014,43（2）:199–209.
97 Yang C H,Huang C H,Hou T C T. Tax incentives and R & D activity:Firm-level evidence from Taiwan[J]. Research Policy,2012,41（9）:1578–1588.
98 Yang H B,Zheng Y F,Zaheer A. Asymmetric learning capabilities and stock market returns[J]. Academy of Management Journal,2015,58（2）:356–374.
99 Yi S S,Shin H. Endogenous formation of research coalitions with spillovers[J]. International Journal of Industrial Organization,2000,18（2）:229–256.
100 Zirulia L. The role of spillovers in R & D network formation[J]. Economics of Innovation and New Technology,2012,21（1）:83–105.
引用本文
黄少卿, 从佳佳, 巢宏. 研发联盟组织治理研究述评及未来展望[J]. 外国经济与管理, 2016, 38(6): 63–81.
导出参考文献，格式为：
下一篇：网上个性化推荐研究述评与展望
