Adding Party building provisions in corporate articles is conducive to safeguarding the statutory status of Party organizations in the corporate governance structure. And it can help to improve enterprises’ ability of political governance. After implementing this practice, the internal management and decision-making of enterprises might be deeply influenced by Party organizations, and thus the cost control level might be changed. This paper focuses on the impact of this practice on cost stickiness and analyzes its functional mechanism. Cost stickiness refers to the asymmetric cost change in response to sales change, and it reflects the tendency of enterprises to hold on to resources in the downturns. Based on a research sample of A-share listed companies from 2013 to 2018, we apply the difference-in-differences approach to examine the effect of adding Party building provisions in corporate articles on cost stickiness. We manually collect data on listed companies that have implemented this practice. The results show that the stickiness level of enterprise total operating cost is significantly reduced after implementing the practice, and this change is achieved by mitigating the dual agency problems. As the statutory status of Party organizations is established, Party organizations in enterprises have more motivation and ability to participate in the operation and management of enterprises. Thus, managers are subject to greater scrutiny by Party organizations. In this case, managers will constrain their opportunistic behaviors, leading to lower cost stickiness. In addition, Party organizations help to protect the interest of minority shareholders. The increasing difficulty of resource extraction of majority shareholders leads to a reduction in expropriation behaviors such as asset occupation, which in turn lessens enterprise cost stickiness. The participation of Party organizations in corporate governance also means that they guide shareholders and management to make decisions in line with the spirit of the Party by means of cultural publicity and spirit guidance, so as to reduce self-interested behaviors that are contrary to the spirit of the Party, thus alleviating the dual agency problem of enterprises. The findings indicate that Party organization governance contributes to optimizing the resource allocation decision of managers and improving the efficiency of cost management. Further research finds that the relationship between the practice and cost stickiness is moderated by the ownership structure of enterprises, and it is more significant in the case of more dispersed ownership structure, lower ownership constraints, and lower management shareholding. Mediation mechanism tests show that adding Party building provisions in corporate articles can indeed reduce cost stickiness by alleviating the dual agency problems. The innovation of this paper is mainly reflected in two aspects: First, this paper contributes to the literature on the determinants of cost stickiness by documenting a new way of corporate governance. Through combining Party building and cost stickiness, the study examines the impact of political governance on cost stickiness. The findings expand the channel of enterprise cost management. Second, different from the existing research methods, this paper uses the difference-in-differences approach to examine the dynamic changes of cost stickiness before and after the Party building reform. It provides relatively rigorous scientific evidence for the implementation of adding Party building provisions in corporate articles, and provides guidance for Chinese listed companies to properly and effectively embed the Party organization into the corporate governance structure.
/ Journals / Foreign Economics & Management
Foreign Economics & Management
LiZengquan, Editor-in-Chief
ZhengChunrong, Vice Executive Editor-in-Chief
YinHuifang HeXiaogang LiuJianguo, Vice Editor-in-Chief
Adding Party Building Provisions in Corporate Articles and Enterprise Cost Stickiness: Based on the Interpretation of Party Organization Governance
Foreign Economics & Management Vol. 43, Issue 10, pp. 21 - 34 (2021) DOI:10.16538/j.cnki.fem.20210508.203
Summary
References
Summary
[1] Chen Kejing. Can non-controlling large shareholders' exit threats reduce agency cost[J]. Nankai Business Review, 2019,22(04):161-175.
[2] Cheng Haiyan, Li Minghui. Communist party' participation in corporate governance and charitable donation[J]. Journal of Business Economics,2020(05):48-61.
[3] Han Meini, Wang Fusheng. Research on the impact of accounting information quality on the value effects of innovation[J]. Management Review,2016,28(10):97-110.
[4] Li Minghui, Cheng Haiyan. Influence of the CPC's participation in corporate governance on risk-taking of listed companies[J]. Economic Review,2020(05):17-31.
[5] Li Minghui, Liu Xiaoxia, Cheng Haiyan. The effect of CPC’s participation in governance on corporate tax avoidance behaviors[J]. Journal of Finance and Economics,2020,46(03):49-64.
[6] Li Shigang, Zhang Weidong. Study on the role of party organizations participating in the boards of directors of private enterprises[J]. Auditing Research,2018(04):120-128.
[7] Liang Shangkun. Will institutional investor ownership affect companies' stickiness of cost?[J]. Management World,2018,34(12):133-148.
[8] Liu Huilong, Qi Yunfei, Wang Chengfang. On the cost stickiness difference between companies with different layers in pyramidal business group[J]. Accounting Research,2017(07):82-88+97.
[9] Liu Xuexin, Kong Xiaoxu, Wang Kai. The party organization governance and board of directors objections in Chinese state-owned firms: Evidence from the resolution voting of board of directors in listed firms[J]. Management World,2020,36(05):116-133+13.
[10] Ma Lianfu, Wang Yuanfang, Shen Xiaoxiu. Party governance, redundant employees and executive compensation contract in state owned enterprises[J]. Management World,2013(05):100-115+130.
[11] Xu Guangwei, Li Jianqiao, Liu Xing. The effect of the party organization embedding on private enterprises social responsibility investment ——An analysis using by private enterprise survey data[J]. Soft Science,2019,33(08):26-31+38.
[12] Xu Xixiong, Yan Youliang. Party branch embeddedness, official promotion and employment protection: Empirical evidence from a survey of Chinese private firms[J]. Foreign Economics & Management,2021,43(03):72-88.
[13] Xu Xixiong, Zhan Heng, Li Wanli. Party branches, policy perception and new investment of private enterprises[J]. Foreign Economics & Management,2020,42(10):3-16.
[14] Yang Wenjun, He Jie, Lu Zhengfei. The threshold regression on equity restriction and firm value in family business[J]. Accounting Research,2016(11):38-45+95.
[15] Zhang Hannan, Sun Shimin, Ma Zhiying. A study on the formation mechanism of senior executive compensation stickiness: From the perspective of tunneling[J]. Accounting Research,2019(04):65-73.
[16] Zheng Dengjin, Xie Deren, Yuan Wei. The CPC party organizations in privately-controlled firms and earnings management[J]. Accounting Research,2020(05):62-79.
[17] Zheng Dengjin, Xie Deren. Party organizations in Chinese privately owned firms and corporate donations[J]. Journal of Financial Research,2019(09):151-168.
[18] Anderson M C, Banker R D, Janakiraman S N. Are selling, general, and administrative costs “sticky”?[J]. Journal of Accounting Research,2003, 41(1): 47-63.
[19] Chen C X, Lu H, Sougiannis T. The agency problem, corporate governance, and the asymmetrical behavior of selling, general, and administrative costs[J]. Contemporary Accounting Research,2012, 29(1): 252-282.
[20] Gantchev N, Sevilir M, Shivdasani A. Activism and empire building[J]. Journal of Financial Economics,2020, 138(2): 526-548.
Cite this article
Li Jiyuan, Wang Fangjun, Zhao Hongsheng, et al. Adding Party Building Provisions in Corporate Articles and Enterprise Cost Stickiness: Based on the Interpretation of Party Organization Governance[J]. Foreign Economics & Management, 2021, 43(10): 21-34.
Export Citations as:
For
ISSUE COVER
RELATED ARTICLES